Between Constitutional Nationalism and Human Rights - the Future of the Rule of Law in Bosnia and Herzegovina?

Benjamin Nurkić, Suad Murselović

Abstract


This paper analyzes the constitutional position of Bosnia and Herzegovina (BiH) between constitutional nationalism and human rights. In its judgments in Sejdić and Finci v. BiH, and Zornić v. BiH, the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) found that the BiH Constitution was not in line with the European Convention on Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (ECHR). Namely, the privilege of the three constituent peoples in the Constitution of BiH, the ECHR was assessed as contrary to the prohibited discrimination prescribed by the ECHR. In this sense, the paper analyzes the current Bosnian constitutional model of a form of consociational democracy or constitutional nationalism. The authors analyze the presumption of the ECtHR in terms of the (non) existence of a legitimate goal for maintaining discriminatory provisions in the Constitution of BiH. Also, the paper analyzes the importance of the implementation of the ECtHR judgment for the future of the rule of law in BiH.

Keywords


constitutional nationalism; human rights; ECtHR; ECHR; consociational democracy

Full Text:

PDF

References


Arat, Zehra (1999), ˝Human Rights and Democracy: Expanding or Contracting?˝, Polity, 32(1), 119-144.

Arlović, Mato (2018), ˝Konstitutivnost naroda – bitni element konstitutivnosti europske BiH˝, Mostariensia: Časopis za društvene i humanističke znanosti, 22(1), 25-57.

Banović, Damir, Saša Gavrić, Mariña Barreiro Mariño (2021), The Political System of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Springer, Cham.

Bardutzky, Samo (2010), ˝The Strasbourg Court on the Dayton Constitution˝, European Constitutional Law Review, 6(2), 309-333.

Ballestrem, Carl (1998), ˝Narodni suverenitet u ustavnoj državi˝, Politička misao, 35(3), 64-77.

Begić, Zlatan, Zlatan Delić (2013), ˝Constituency of peoples in the constitutional system of Bosnia and Herzegovina: Chasing fair solutions˝, International Journal of Constitutional Law, 11(2), 447-465.

Begić, Zlatan (2016), ˝Legal Capacities of the Dayton Constitution in the Process of Accession of Bosnia and Herzegovina to European Union˝, Journal of Politics and Law, 9(1), 11-20.

Bieber, Florian (2000), ˝Bosnia-Herzegovina and Lebanon: Historical Lessons of Two Multireligious States˝, Third World Quarterly, 21(2), 269-281.

Capotorti, Francesco (1977), Study on the rights of persons belonging to ethnic, religious and linguistic minorities, UN Subcommission on Prevention of Discrimination and Protection of Minorities. Special Rapporteur to carry out a Study on the Rights of Persons belonging to Ethnic, Religious and Linguistic Minorities

Caratan, Branko (1998), ˝Nacionalni fenomen i akomodacija interesa: pretpostavke postkomunističke tranzicije — II. dio˝, Politička misao, 35(3), 212-233.

Chandler, David (2000), Bosnia Faking Democracy after Dayton, Pluto Press, London and Sterling

Choudhry, Sujit (2010), ˝After the Rights Revolution: Bills of Rights in the Postconflict State˝, Annual Review of Law and Social Science, 6, 301-322.

Delić, Demirel (2018), ˝Sistemske posljedice Odluke USBiH u predmetu dr. Božo Ljubić – nužnost strukturalnih izmjena dvodomnog uređenja zakonodavnog tijela˝, Sveske za javno pravo, 33, 20-32.

Feldman, David (2013), ˝Sovereignties in Strasbourg˝, u: Richard Rawlings, Peter Leyland, and Alison Young (ur.), Sovereignty and the Law: Domestic, European, and International Perspectives, Oxford University Press

Ginsburg, Tom (2013), ˝Courts and Consociations (review)˝, ICONnect (ICON blog).

Graziadei, Stefan (2016), ˝Democracy v Human Rights? The Strasbourg Court and the Challenge of Power Sharing˝, European Constitutional Law Review, 12(1), 54-84.

Greenfeld, Liah (1993), ˝Nationalism and Democracy: The Nature of the Relationship and the Cases of England, France, and Russia˝, u: Weil, F. D. (ur.), Researach on Democracy and Society, JAI press Inc, Vol. 1, 327-352.

Hayden, Robert M (1993), ˝Constitutional Nationalism in the Formerly Yugoslav Republics˝, Slavic Review, 51(1), 1–15.

Hayek, Friedrich (1998), Poredak slobode, Global Book, Novi Sad

Issacharoff, Samuel (2008), ˝Democracy and collective decision making˝, International Journal of Constitutional Law, 6(2), 231-266.

Išerić, Harun (2017), ˝Izbor domaćih sudija Ustavnog suda BiH kao ustavni običaj contra constitutionem˝, Pravna misao, 48(11/12), 17-47.

Kaldor, Mary, (2016), ˝How Peace Agreements Undermine the Rule of Law in New War Settings˝, Global Policy, 7(2), 146-155.

Kasapović, Mirjana (2005), ˝Bosnia and Herzegovina: Consociational or Liberal Democracy?˝, Politička misao, 42(5), 3-30.

Kulenović, Nedim (2016), Sud kao kreator politika?: Uloga i efekti Ustavnog suda BiH u demokratskoj tranziciji i konsolidaciji, Analitika – Centar za društvena istraživanja, Sarajevo

Lavić, Senadin (2020), ˝Bosanska Nacija: Demokratska nacija-država versus država zatočena u etnopolitiku˝, Pregled: Časopis za društvena pitanja, 1(1), 21-43.

Lijphart, Arend (1977), Democracy in Plural Societies: A Comparative Exploration, Yale University Press, Connecticut

Lijphart, Arend (2008), Thinking about Democracy: Power Sharing and Majority Rule in Theory and Practice, Routledge, New York

Lovrenović, Ivan (1999), Unutarnja Zemlja. Kratki pregled kulturne povijesti Bosne i Hercegovine, Durieux, Zagreb

Madsen, Rask Mikael (2015), ˝The Legitimization Strategies of International Judges: The Case of the European Court of Human Rights˝, u: Bobek, Michal (ur.), Selecting Europe’s Judges, Oxford University Press, 259-278.

Malcolm, Noel (2011), Bosna: Kratka povijest, Buybook, Sarajevo

Mansfield, Morawiec, Anna (2003), ˝Ethnic but Equal: The Quest for a New Democratic Order in Bosnia and Herzegovina˝, Columbia Law Review, 103(8), 2052-2093.

Marković, Goran (2012), Bosanskohercegovački federalizam, Službeni glasnik i University Press – izdanja Magistrat, Beograd i Sarajevo

McCrudden, Christopher, Brendan O’Leary (2013), ˝Courts and Consociations, or How Human Rights Courts May De-stabilize Power-sharing Settlements˝, The European Journal of International Law, 24(2), 477-501.

McCrudden, Christopher, Brendan O’Leary (2013), Courts and Consociations: Human Rights versus Power-Sharing, Oxford University Press, Oxford

Mesić, Milan (2013), ˝Pojam nacionalnih manjina i njihovo političko predstavljanje: Slučaj Hrvatske˝, Politička misao, 50(4), 107-131.

Milanović, Marko (2010), ˝Sejdić & Finci v. Bosnia and Herzegovina. App. Nos. 27996/06 & 34836/06˝, The American Journal of International Law, 104(4), 636-641.

Miraščić, Dženeta (2012), Država i nacija u multikulturalnom društvu, Službeni list BiH, Sarajevo

O’Flynn, Ian (2006), Deliberative Democracy and Divided Societies, Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh

Özkirimli, Umut (2000), Theories of Nationalism: A Critical Introduction, Macmillan, Basingstoke

Petričušić, Antonija (2014), ˝Kako osigurati opstanak ‘Ostalih’: Dokidanje institucionalne diskriminacije nacionalnih manjina u Bosni i Hercegovini˝, u: Potočnjak, Željko, Ivana Grgurev, Andrea Grgić (ur.), Perspektive antidiskriminacijskog prava. Pravni fakultet u Zagrebu, Zagreb, 199-236.

Pezo, Vladimir (2007), Pravni leksikon, Leksikografski zavod Miroslav Krleža, Zagreb

Posavec, Zvonko (1998), ˝Legitimacija ustavne države između moralnog univerzalizma i nacionalno-demokratskog partikularizma˝, Politička misao, 35(3), 5-16.

Rangelov, Iavor (2014), Nationalism and the Rule of Law, Cambridge University Press, New York.

Rosga, Ann Janette (2010), ˝The Bosnian police, multi-ethnic democracy, and the race of European civilization˝, Ethnic and Racial Studies, 33(4), 675-695.

Rothchild, Donald, Philip Roeder (2005), ˝Power Sharing as an Impediment to Peace and Democracy˝, u: Roeder, Philip, Donald Rothchild (ur.), Sustainable Peace: Power and Democracy After Civil Wars, Cornell UP, Ithaca, 29-50.

Sadurski, Wojciech (2014), Rights Before Courts A Study of Constitutional Courts in Postcommunist States of Central and Eastern Europe, Springer, New York i London

Sarajlić, Eldar (2010), ˝Bosnian Elections and Recurring Ethnonationalisms: The Ghost of the Nation State˝, Journal on Ethnopolitics and Minority Issues in Europe, 9(2), 66-88.

Schneckener, Ulrich (2002), ˝Making Power-Sharing Work: Lessons from Successes and Failures in Ethnic Conflict Regulation˝, Journal of Peace Research, 39(2), 203-228.

Sekulić, Dušan (2003), ˝Građanski i etnički identitet: Slučaj Hrvatske˝, Politička misao, 40(2), 140-166.

Sisk, Timothy (1996), Power Sharing and International Mediation in Ethnic Conflicts, United States Institute of Peace

Smooha, Sammy (2002), ˝Types of democracy and modes of conflict management in ethnically divided societies˝, Nations and Nationalism, 8(4), 423-431.

Steiner, Henry J. (1991), ˝Ideals and Counter-Ideals in the Struggle over Autonomy Regimes for Minorities˝, 66 Notre Dame L. Rev., 1539-1554.

Sweet, Alec Stone (2012), ˝Constitutional Courts˝, u: Rosenfeld, Michel, Andras Sajo (ur.), The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Constitutional Law, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 816-830.

Šarčević, Edin (2009), Dejtonski ustav: Karakteristike i karakteristični problemi, Konrad Adenauer Stiftung, Sarajevo

Trnka, Kasim (2000), Konstitutivnost naroda, Vijeće Kongresa bošnjačkih intelektualaca, Sarajevo

Toal, Gerard, Carl T. Dahlman, (2011), Bosna remade. Ethnic cleansing and its reversal, Oxford University Press, Oxford

Trnka, Kasim (2006), Ustavno pravo, Fakultet za javnu upravu, Sarajevo

Vehabović, Faris (2006), Odnos Ustava Bosne i Hercegovine i Evropske konvencije za zaštitu ljudskih prava i osnovnih sloboda, Asocijacija Alumni Centra za interdisciplinarne postdiplomske studije, Sarajevo

Vujčić, Vladimir (1998), ˝Politička kultura i međunacionalni odnosi u demokraciji˝, Politička misao, 35(2), 25-49.

Vukoja, Ivan, Valentino Grbavac, Ivan Pepić (2018), ˝Meritum i razumijevanje odluke Ustavnog suda BiH U-23-14˝, Mostariensia: Časopis za društvene i humanističke znanosti, 22(1), 523-534.

Zakaria, Fareed (1997), ˝The Rise of Illiberal Democracy˝, Foreign Affairs, 76(6), 22-43.

Zdeb, Aleksandra (2019), ˝Ethno-nationalism and Political Conflict in Bosnia˝, Palgrave Handbook of Ethnicity, 596-610.

Zgodić, Esad (2008), Ideja bosanske nacije i druge teme, Zalihica, Sarajevo

Wakelin, Elyse (2012), ˝The Sejdic and Finci Case: More Than Just a Human Rights Issue?˝, E-International Relations, 1-6.

Wheatley, Steven (2005), Democracy, Minorities and International Law (Cambridge Studies in International and Comparative Law), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Wippman, David (2018), ˝Practical and Legal Constraints on Internal Power Sharing˝, u: Wippman, David (ur.), International Law and Ethnic Conflict, Ithaca, Cornell University Press, NY, 211-241.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.51558/2490-3647.2022.7.1.361

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


ISSN: 2490-3604 (print) ● ISSN: 2490-3647 (online)

Društvene i humanističke studije - DHS is under the Creative Commons licence.