Neoliberal Penal Policy and Prison Privatization

Olivera I. Pavićević, Ljeposava M. Ilijić, Milena D. Milićević

Abstract


The paper analyzes the relationship between neoliberal penalty transformation and prison privatization as part of neoliberal market reform. The neoliberal political and economic project characterized by deregulation, individualization, privatization, and commodification has introduced competition, entrepreneurship, and economic efficiency in areas that previously belonged exclusively to the public sector. The alleged need for greater efficiency has led to an increase in private prisons, and the results of this transformation have shown that it is more about achieving economic efficiency at the expense of quality, competencies, and outcomes of services provided in this sector. In this paper, the starting assumption is that the increase in the number of private prisons does not imply the withdrawal of the state concerning the market. In contrast, it raises the question of the regulatory role of the neoliberal state that enables the market of new fields for profit. As a consequence of the tightening of penal policy, mass incarceration is a mechanism for resolving social conflicts caused by the transformation of social policy. Therefore, private prisons are aimed at making a profit by reflecting the spread of neoliberal rationality throughout society. Withdrawal of assistance and support from the social sector and transfer of exclusive responsibility from the social to the individual responsibility of prisoners as rational neoliberal subjects lead to a reduction of rehabilitation goals. In the context of prison privatization, this transformation leads to turning prisoners into a means of earning or cheap labor.

Keywords


penal policy; neoliberalism; mass incarceration; market; rehabilitation

Full Text:

PDF

References


Ackerman, Alissa, Meghan Sacks, Rich Furman (2014), ˝The new penology revisited: The criminalization of immigration as pacification strategy˝, Justice policy journal, 11(1), 1–20.

Aman, Alfred J. (2005), ˝Privatization, prisons, democracy, and human rights: The need to extend the province of administrative law˝, Indiana journal of global legal studies, 12(2), 511-550.

Bell, Emma (2011), Criminal justice and neoliberalism, Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke

Cavadino, Michael, James Dignan (2006), Penal systems: A comparative approach, Sage, London

Cheliotis, K. Leonidas (2013), ˝Neoliberal capitalism and middle-class punitiveness: Bringing Erich Fromm’s “Materialistic Psychoanalysis” to Penology˝, Punishment & Society, 15(3), 247-273.

Crewe, Ben, Alison Liebling, Susie Hulley (2015), ˝Staff-prisoner relationships, staff professionalism, and the use of authority in public and private sector prisons˝, Law & Social Inquiry, 40(2), 309-344.

Cummings, Andre D. Pond, Adam Lamparello (2016), ˝Private prisons and the new marketplace for crime˝, Wake Forest JL & Pol’y, 6(2), 407-440.

Cummins, Ian (2015), ˝Reading Wacquant: Social work and advanced marginality˝, European Journal of Social Work, 19(2), 1-12

Davies, William (2014), The limits of neoliberalism: Authority, sovereignty and the logic of competition, Sage Publications

Davies, William (2018), ˝The neoliberal state: Power against ‘politics’˝, in: Cahill, Damien, Melinda Cooper, David Primrose, and Martijn Konings (eds.), The Sage handbook of neoliberalism, Sage Publications, 273-283.

De Giorgi, Alessandro (2012), ˝Punishment and political economy˝, in: Simon, Jonathan and Richard Sparks (eds.), The Sage handbook of punishment and society, Sage, London, 40-59.

De Giorgi, Alessandro (2015), ˝Five theses on mass incarceration˝, Social Justice, 42(2), 5-30.

Dolovich, Sharon (2005), ˝State punishment and private prisons˝, Duke Law Journal, 55(3), 437-546.

Feeley, Malcolm, Jonathan Simon (1992), ˝The new penology: Notes on the emerging strategy of corrections and its implications˝, Criminology, 30(4), 449-472.

Feeley, Malcolm, Jonathan Simon (1994), ˝Actuarial justice: The emerging new criminal law˝, in: Nelken, David (ed.), The Futures of Criminology, Sage, London, UK, 173-201.

Freeman, Richard B. (2001), ˝Does the booming economy help explain the fall in crime?˝, in: Blumstein, Alfred, Laurence Steinberg, Carl C. Bell, and Margaret A. Berger (eds.), Perspectives on Crime and Justice: 1999–2000 Lecture Series, Volume IV 23–50, US Department of Justice, Washington, DC

Gaes, Gerald G. (2008), ˝Cost, performance studies look at prison privatization˝, National Institute of Justice Journal, 259, 32-36.

Garland, David (2001), The culture of control: Crime and social order in contemporary society, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, USA

Gilmore, Wilson Ruth (2007), The Golden Gulag: Prisons, surplus, crisis, and opposition in globalizing California, Vol. 21, University of California Press, Berkeley, CA

Harvey, David (2012), A brief history of neoliberalism, Oxford University Press, USA

Ilijić, Ljeposava (2017), ˝Praktične implikacije savremenog penološkog pristupa na institucionalni tretman osuđenika – osvrt na tretman zavisnika”, u: Macanović, Nebojša, Jagoda Petrović, Goran Jovanić (ur.), Društvene devijacije – Anomija društva i posljedice, Univerzitet u Banjoj Luci, Fakultet političkih nauka, 362-371.

Ilijić, Ljeposava, Olivera Pavićević (2020), ˝Od stare ka novoj penologiji – o pojedinim implikacijama nove strategije u korektivnoj praksi˝, Socijalna misao, 98(1), 45-58.

James, Adrian, Keith Bottomley, Alison Liebling, Еmma Clare (1997), Privatizing prisons: Rhetoric and reality, Sage, London

Kuzmančev-Stanojević, Sonja (2021), ˝Sociological aspects of neoliberalism: Genealogy of the mode of domination and violence˝, Doctoral dissertation, Faculty of Philosophy, Novi Sad

Liebling, Alison (2000), ˝Prison officers, policing and the use of discretion˝, Theoretical Criminology, 4(3), 333-357.

Liebling, Аlison, Helen Arnold (2004), Prisons and their moral performance: A study of values, quality, and prison life, Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK

Logan, Charles (1990), Private prisons: Pros and cons, Oxford University Press, New York

Ludlow, Amy (2017), ˝Marketising criminal justice˝, in: Liebling, Alison, Shad Maruna, and Lesley McAra (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Criminology (6th ed.), Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK, 914-937.

Lynch, Mona (2011), ˝Theorizing punishment: Reflections on Wacquant’s punishing the poor˝, Critical Sociology, 37(2), 237-244.

Maltz, Michael (1984), Recidivism, Originally published by Academic Press, Inc., Orlando, FL

Marko, Karoline (2021), ˝Serving the public good? – A corpus-assisted discourse analysis of private prisons and for-profit incarceration in the United States˝, Frontiers in Communication, 6, 672110.

Metzger, Gillian (2003), ˝Privatization as Delegation˝, Columbia Law Review, 6, 1367-1502.

McElligott, Greg (2007), ˝Bearing the neoconservative burden? Frontline work in prisons˝, Social Justice, 34(3/4), 78-97.

Mudge, Stephanie (2008), ˝What is neo-liberalism?˝, Socio-Economic Review, 6(4), 703-731

Pavićević, Olivera, Ljeposava Ilijić (2022), ˝Social inequality and mass imprisonment˝, Sociologija, 64(4), 563-583.

Peacock, Marian, Mary Turner, Sandra Varey (2018),˝‘We call is jail craft’: The erosion of the protective discourses drawn on by prison officers dealing with aging and dying prisoners in the neoliberal, carceral system˝, Sociology 52(6), 1152-1168.

Petković, Krešimir (2010), ˝Politika i nasilje u tranziciji˝, Političke analize: tromjesečnik za hrvatsku i međunarodnu politiku, 1(2), 25-30.

Petković, Krešimir (2016), ˝Kazna u Americi: kaznena politika u SAD-u u vrijeme kaznenog zaokreta i nakon njega˝, Politička misao, 53(3), 111-138.

Rusche, Georg, Otto Kirchheimer (1929) (reprint 2003), Punishment and social structure, Transaction Publishers, New Brunswick and London

Selman, Donna, Paul Leighton (2010), Punishment for sale: Private prisons, big business, and the incarceration binge, Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Maryland

Shichor, David (1995), Punishment for profit: Private prisons / public concerns, Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA,

Sigler, Mary (2010), ˝Private prisons, public functions, and the meaning of punishment˝, Florida State University Law Review, 38(1), 149-178.

Simon, Jonathan (1993), Poor Discipline, University of Chicago Press, Chicago

Simon, Jonathan (2013), ˝Punishment and the political technologies of the body˝, The Sage Handbook of Punishment and Society, Sage, London, 60-89.

Simon, Jonathan, Malcolm Feeley (2003), ˝The form and limits of the new penology˝, Punishment and Social Control, 2, 75-116.

Sinden, Jeff (2003), ˝The problem of prison privatization: The US experience˝, in: Coyle, Andrew, Allison Campbell, Rodney Neufeld (eds.), Capitalist punishment: Prison privatization and human rights, Clarity Press - Zed Books, Atlanta - London, 39-47.

Slingeneyer, Thibaut (2007), ˝The new penology: a grid for analyzing the transformations of penal discourses, techniques and objectives˝, Champ penal /Penal field, 4, 2-22.

Soss, Joe, Richard C. Fording, Sanford F. Schram (2011), Disciplining the poor: Neoliberal paternalism and the persistent power of race, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago and London

Teague, Michael (2012), ˝Neoliberalism, prisons and probation in the United States and England and Wales˝, in: Whitehead, Philip and Paul Crawshaw (eds.), Organizing neoliberalism: Markets, privatization and justice, Anthem Press, London, 45-80.

Verkuil, Paul R. (2007), Outsourcing sovereignty: Why privatization of government functions threatens democracy and what we can do about it, Cambridge University Press, New York

Wacquant, Loïc (2009), Punishing the poor: The neoliberal government of social insecurity, Duke University Press, London

Wacquant, Loïc (2010), ˝Crafting the neoliberal state: workfare, prison fare, and social insecurity˝, Sociological forum, 25(2), 97-220.

Wacquant, Loïc (2013), ˝Foreword: Probing the meta-prison˝, in: Jeffrey Ian Ross (ed.), The globalization of supermax prisons, Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, ix-xiv

Wacquant, Loïc (2022), The Invention of the ‘Underclass’: A Study in the Politics of Knowledge, Polity Press, Cambridge & Medford.

Wood, Philip (2003),˝The rise of the prison industrial complex in the United States˝, in: Coyle, Andrew, Allison Campbell and Rodney Neufeld (eds.), Capitalist Punishment: Prison Privatization and Human Rights, Clarity Press, Atlanta, 16-29.

Xenakis, Sappho, Leonidas K. Cheliotis (2018), ˝Neoliberalism and the politics of imprisonment˝, in: DeKeseredy, Walter S. and Molly Dragiewicz (eds.), Routledge Handbook of Critical Criminology, Routledge international handbooks (2nd). Routledge, Abingdon,UK, 249-259.

Clark, Kelsey (2016), ˝Prisons for profit: Neoliberal rationality’s transformation of America’s prisons˝, Senior Independent Study Theses. Paper 7242. Available on: https://openworks.wooster.edu/independentstudy/7242, (26. 09. 2021)

Young, Sydney (2020), ˝Capital and the carceral state: Prison privatization in the United States and United Kingdom˝. Available on: https://hir.harvard.edu/ us-uk-prison-privatization/ (09. 07. 2020)

Kilgore, James (2013), ˝Confronting prison slave labourcamps and other myths˝, Social Justice Blog, 28 August. Available on: http://www.socialjusticejournal.org/ confronting-prison-slave-labor-camps-and-other-myths/, (06. 06. 2022)

Wacquant, Loïc (2011), ˝The Wedding of workfare and prison fare revisited˝. Available on: https://www4.shu.ac.uk/research/cresr/sites/shu.ac.uk/files/wed- ding-workfare-prisonfare-revisited.pdf, (08. 07. 2022)




DOI: https://doi.org/10.51558/2490-3647.2023.8.1.595

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


ISSN: 2490-3604 (print) ● ISSN: 2490-3647 (online)

Društvene i humanističke studije - DHS is under the Creative Commons licence.