Constructing Meaning, Shaping Society: The Calculability and Cancellability of Conversational Implicatures

Martina Blečić

Abstract


This paper investigates the features of calculability and cancellability of conversational implicatures, focusing on their societal importance. The analysis of the carnival effigy Škuribando Fureštić is used to illustrate how conversational implicatures can be employed to maintain the social status quo and perpetuate stereotypes. This is not to suggest that implicatures are more prominent than explicit communication in achieving these effects, but rather that their indirect nature is often exploited to avoid responsibility for the conveyed message. This paper challenges the notion that implicatures are easily cancellable and deniable, arguing that cancellation often leads to logical implausibility, thereby indicating faulty communication.

Keywords


conversational implicature; cancellability; calculability; indirect meaning; con-ceptual engineering; societal impact

Full Text:

PDF

References


Åkerman, Jonas (2015), ˝Infelicitous cancellation: the explicit cancellability test for conversational implicature revisited˝, Austaliasan journal of Philosophy, 93(3), 465-474.

Blečić, Martina (2021), ˝Implicitness, Logical Form and Arguments˝, Croatian Journal of Philosophy, 21, 405-418.

Blečić, Martina (2019a), ˝Poništavanje i zadano značenje˝, in: Snežana Gudurić i Biljana Radić-Bojanić (ur.), Jezici u kulturi u vremenu i prostoru, VIII/1, Novi Sad, 611–620.

Blečić, Martina (2019b), ˝Prednost izračunavanja razgovornih implikatura pred njihovim poništavanjem: argumentacijski pristup˝, Colloquium: New Philologies, 4(2); 36-51.

Blome-Tillmann, Michael (2008), ˝Conversational Implicature and the Cancellability Test˝, Analysis, 68, 156-160.

Bohlmann, Markus (2023), ˝Conceptual engineering and conceptual change. An argument for the learnability of ameliorated concepts˝, Inquiry, 1–29.; https://doi.org/10.1080/0020174X.2023.2289161

Burgess, Alexis, David Plunkett (2020), ˝On the relation between conceptual engineering and conceptual ethics˝, Ratio, 33(4), 281–294.

Brown, Penelope, Stephen C. Levinson (1987), Politeness: Some universals in language usage, Cambridge University Press.

Campbell, Jessica (2017), ˝The First Brave Woman Who Alleged ‘Sexual Harassment’˝, Legacy.com; https://www.legacy.com/news/culture-and-history/ the-first-brave-woman-who-alleged-sexual-harassment/

Dennett, Daniel C. (1971), ˝Intentional Systems˝, Journal of Philosophy, 68, 87–106.

Dennett, Daniel C. (2009), ˝Intentional Systems Theory˝, in: Brian McLaugh- lin (ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Philosophy of Mind, 339–350-

Dmitrović, Saša (1995), Riječki karneval, Bibliotheca Civica, Rijeka

Gašpert, Šanja (2024), ˝To nije maškarana zabava, već rasizam. Škuribando Fureštić sablaznio Hrvatsku, a danas ga dižu – opet˝ Novi list, 25. siječanj 2024.

Grice, Paul H. (1989), ˝Logic and Conversation˝, in: Studies in the Way of Words, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts; London, England, 22–40.

Haslanger, Sally (2000), ˝Gender and race: (What) are they? (What) do we want them to be?˝, Noûs, 34(1), 31–55.

Haugh, Michael (2008) ˝The place of intention in the interactional achievement of implicature˝, In: J. L. Mey and I. Kecskés (eds.), Intention, Common Ground and the Egocentric Speaker-Hearer, De Gruyter

Horisk, Claire (2024), Dangerous Jokes: How Racism and Sexism Weaponize Humor, online edn, Oxford Academic, New York; 22 Feb. 2024: https://doi. org/10.1093/oso/9780197691496.001.0001

Jaszczolt, Katarzyna M. (2005), Default Semantics: Foundations of a Compositional Theory of Acts of Communication, Oxford University Press, Oxford

Jaszczolt, Katarzyna M. (2010), ˝Default Semantics˝, in: B. Heine and H. Narrog (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Linguistic Analysis, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 215–246.

Jaszczolt, Katarzyna M. (2016), Meaning in Linguistic Interaction: Semantics, Metasemantics, Philosophy of Language, Oxford University Press

Kant, Immanuel (1998), Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals, Translated by Mary Gregor, Cambridge University Press

Kharusi, Nafla S. (2014), ˝Female Camel Nomenclature among Arabia’s Bedouins˝, Names A Journal of Onomastics, 62(2), 86-99.

Koslow, Allison (2022), ˝Meaning change and changing meaning˝, Synthese, 200(94); https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-022-03563-8

Krupnik, Igor, Claudio Aporta, Shari Gearheard, Gita J. Laidler, Lene Kielsen Holm (Eds.), (2010), SIKU: Knowing our ice, Springer

Lee, James, Steven Pinker (2010), ˝Rationales for indirect speech: The theory of the strategic speaker˝, Psychological Review, 117(3), 785–807.

Macagno, Fabrizio (2023), ˝Practical (un)cancellability˝, Journal of Pragmatics, 215. 84-95.

Mercier, Hugo, Dan Sperber (2017), The Enigma of Reason, Harvard University Pres, Zagreb

Opačić, Tamara, Kristijan Grđan, Marko Jurčić (2012) Imamo obitelj! Vodič za životne partnerice, životne partnere i dugine obitelji: Naša prava iz živo- tnog partnerstva i mogućnosti planiranja LGBTIQ roditeljstva u Hrvatskoj, Zagreb Pride

Pavlica, Valentina (2024), ˝Skandalozni potez maškara u općini Čavle. Objesili pusta u liku stranog radnika˝, Telegram, https://www.telegram.hr/vijesti/skandalozni-potez-maskara-u-opcini-cavle-objesili-lika-stranog-radnika-kazu-da-zele-upozoriti-na-devijacije-koje-sustav-nije-rijesio/

Ožanić, Marta (2024), ˝Sve što ste željeli znati o Čavjanskom pustu˝, Art Kvart, https://artkvart.hr/sve-sto-ste-zeljeli-znati-o-cavjanskom-pustu/

Sbisà, Marina (2001), ˝Intentions from the other side˝, in: G. Cosenza (ed.) Paul Grice’s Heritage, Brepols, Turnhout, 185-206.

Sbisà, Marina (2006), ˝Two Conceptions of Rationality in Grice’s Theory of Implicature˝, in: Elvio Baccarini, Snježana Prijić-Samaržija (eds.) Rationality in Belief and Action, Filozofski fakultet u Rijeci, Rijeka, 233-247.

Sperber, Dan, Deirdre Wilson (1986), Relevance: Communication and cognition, Blackwell,

Sullivan, Arthur (2017), ˝Evaluating the cancellability test˝, Journal of Pragmatics, 121, 162-174.

Walton, Douglas (1989), ˝Dialogue theory for critical thinking˝, Argumentation 3, 169-184.

Weiner, Matthew (2006), ˝Are all conversational implicatures cancellable?˝, Analysis, 66(290), 127–130.

Whorf, Benjamin Lee (1956), Language, thought, and reality: selected writings, Technology Press of Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Mass.

Winter, Bronwyn, Maxime Forest, Réjane Sénac (2018), Global Perspectives on Same-Sex Marriage: A Neo-Institutional Approach, Palgrave Macmillan




DOI: https://doi.org/10.51558/2490-3647.2024.9.2.419

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


ISSN: 2490-3604 (print) ● ISSN: 2490-3647 (online)

Društvene i humanističke studije - DHS is under the Creative Commons licence.