Investment Arbitration: A Model for Resolving Property Law Disputes on the Example of Bosnia and Herzegovina and the Republic of Croatia?

Larisa Velić, Aida Mulalić, Enis Omerović

Abstract


Property disputes between Bosnia and Herzegovina and the Republic of Croatia are a reality that burdens the entirety of international diplomatic relations between two neighboring countries of the same subregion. After the dissolution of the Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia (SFRY), numerous issues arose, of which property rights are among the most important. The republics of the former SFRY, as well as natural and legal persons, had their property in the entire territory of Yugoslavia, so it was necessary to adequately protect the existing rights. In this regard, in 2001, the Successor States of the SFRY concluded the Agreement on Succession, in which they agreed on movable and immovable property through seven Annexes. Bosnia and Herzegovina (BiH) started from the view that the comprehensive implementation of the Succession Agreement is the basis of permanent, stable, and friendly relations between the Contracting States and took all that was necessary to return the property claimed by the Successor States. However, the Republic of Croatia did not return the property in the way that Bosnia and Herzegovina did, and the first country started to violate the aforementioned multilateral international agreement. Given that the Agreement on Succession does not offer adequate solutions for the peaceful settlement of international disputes between the Contracting Parties, the paper analyzes the possibility of settlement of said disputes based on investment arbitration, which as a model for the settlement of international disputes is not an instrument used by individuals and legal entities from BiH into a sufficient extent. Equally, in this light, we explore the legal possibilities of the concluded Agreement on the Promotion and Protection of Investments between Bosnia and Herzegovina and the Republic of Croatia (bilateral investment treaty) and present the future of investment arbitration from the perspective of the European Union.

Keywords


property dispute; property; ownership; Succession Agreement; bilateral investment treaty; investment arbitration; jurisdiction ratione temporis

Full Text:

PDF

References


Armstrong, David, Theo Farrell, Hélène Lambert (2007), International Law and International Relations, Cambridge University Press

Austin, John (1995), The Province of Jurisprudence Determined, W. E. Rumble (ed.), Cambridge University Press

Baltag, Crina, Ana Stanić (eds.) (2020), The Future of Investment Treaty Arbitration in the EU: Intra-EU BITs, the Energy Charter Treaty, and the Multilateral Investment Court, Wolters Kluwer

Bilas, Vlatka, Adela Videc (2001), ˝Učinkovitost sustava za rješavanje sporova Svjetske trgovinske organizacije˝, Zbornik Ekonomskog fakulteta u Zagrebu, 9(2), 175-194.

Born, Gary B. (2015), International Arbitration: Law and Practice, 2. izd., Wolters Kluwer

Brownlie, Ian (2003), Principles of Public International Law, 6. izd., Oxford University Press

Bungenberg, Marc, Enes Bikić, Larisa Velić (2019), ˝Međunarodna zaštita nekretnina u vlasništvu BiH koje se nalaze u Republici Hrvatskoj˝, ZIPS, br. 1413.

Burgstaller, Markus (2014), ˝Dispute Settlement in EU International Investment Agreements with Third States: Three Salient Problems˝, Journal of World Investment and Trade, 15(3-4), 551-569.

Čolović, Vladimir (2015), ˝Sporazum o pitanjima sukcesije – zaštita privatne svojine˝, Godišnjak Fakulteta pravnih nauka, 5(5), 40-53.

De Vita, Glauc, Kevin Lawler (2004), ˝Foreign Direct Investment and its Determinants: A Look to the Past, A View to the Future˝, u: H. S. Kehal (ed.), Foreign Investment in Developing Countries, Palgrave Macmillan

Degan, Vladimir-Đuro (2011), Međunarodno pravo, Školska knjiga, Zagreb

Dimopoulos, Angelos (2011), EU Foreign Investment Law, Oxford University Press

Dolzer, Rudolf, Christoph Schreuer (2008), Principles of International Investment Law, Oxford University Press

Dörr, Oliver, Kirsten Schmalenbach (eds.) (2018), Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties. A Commentary, Springer, Berlin

Đajić, Sanja (2012) Međunarodno pravosuđe, Službeni glasnik, Beograd

Gallus, Nick (2016), ˝Article 28 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties and Investment Treaty Decisions˝, ICSID Review - Foreign

Investment Law Journal, 31(2), 290- 313.

Gantz, David A. (2020), An Introduction to the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement: Understanding the New NAFTA, Edward Elgar Publishing

Heiskanen, Veijo A. (2018), ˝Entretemps: Is There a Distinction Between Jurisdiction Ratione Temporis and Subtantive Protection Ratione Temporis˝, u: Y. Banifatemi (ed.), Jurisdiction in Investment Treaty Arbitration, IAI Series on International Arbitration No. 8, Juris Publishing, 297-320

Henriksen, Anders (2011), International Law, 2. izd., Oxford University Press

ICSID (2006), ICSID Convention, Regulations and Rules

International Center for Settlement of Investment Disputes, United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (2003), Dispute Settlement, Requirements Ratione Materiae, United Nations

Komnenić, Dušanka (2018), Pravo na mirno uživanje imovine i Evropski sud za ljudska prava – pravo na mirno uživanje imovine u presudama i odlukama Evropskog suda za ljudska prava donetim u postupcima u kojima su bivše jugoslovenske republike bile odgovorne države, Službeni glasnik, Beograd

Kriebaum, Ursula, Christoph Schreuer, Rudolf Dolzer (2022), Principles of International Investment Law, 3. izd., Oxford University Press

Lazić, Miroslav (2011), ˝Pretvorba (transformacija) prava na nekretninama u društvenom vlasništvu u Republici Srbiji˝, Zbornik Pravnog fakulteta Sveučilišta u Rijeci, 32(1), 215-233

Lester, Simon (2015), ˝Reforming the International Investment Law System˝, Maryland Journal of International Law 30(1),70-81.

McLachlan, Campbell, Laurence Shore, Matthew Weiniger (2017), International Investment Arbitration: Substantive Principles, 2. izd., Oxford University Press

Meskic, Zlatan, Mohamad Albakjaji, Enis Omerovic, Hussein Alhussein (2022), ˝Transnational Consumer Protection in E-Commerce: Lessons Learned from the European Union and the United States˝, International Journal of Service Science, Management, Engineering, and Technology (IJSSMET), 13(1), 1-15.

Mihaj, Senka, Aleksandar Filen (2018), ˝Primena priloga G Sporazuma o pitanjima sukcesije˝, Pravo i privreda, 56(4-6), 396-410.

Mulalić, Aida (2018), ˝Međunarodni kontekst i specifičnosti investiciono-pravnih odnosa˝, Anali Pravnog fakulteta Univerziteta u Zenici, 11, 91-107.

Mulalić, Aida, Enis Omerović (2019), ˝Comprehensive Trade Agreement (CETA) – institucionalizirani pristup EU rješavanju međunarodnih investicionih sporova˝, Revija za pravo i ekonomiju, 20(1), 270-287.

Mulalić, Aida, Enis Omerović (2021), ˝Materijalno-pravni i procesno-pravni aspekti korelativnog djelovanja Svjetske trgovinske organizacije i Među- narodnog monetarnog fonda kao međunarodnih organizacija˝, Anali Pravnog fakulteta Univerziteta u Zenici, 14(27), 13-35.

Murphy Sean D. (2022), ˝Temporal Issues Relating to BIT Dispute Resolution˝, ICSID Review, 37(1-2), 51-84.

Newcombe, Andrew, Lluís Paradell (2009), Law and Practice of Investment Treaties: Standards of Treatment, Kluwer Law International

OECD (1996), Benchmark Definition of Foreign Direct Investment, 3. izd., Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development

Orme Jr, William A. (1996), Understanding NAFTA: Mexico, Free Trade, and the New North America, 2. izd., University of Texas Press

Sadiković, Lada (2012), ˝Nadustavni karakter Evropske konvencije o ljudskim pravima u Bosni i Hercegovini˝, Pregled: časopis za društvena pitanja, 1(1), 57-72.

Simonetti, Petar (1999), ˝Trajno pravo korištenja i njegova pretvorba u pravo vlasništva vlasnika zgrade˝, Zbornik Pravnog fakulteta Sveučilišta u Rijeci, 20(2), 487-528.

Shaw, Malcolm N. (2021), International Law, 9. izd., Cambridge University Press

Softić, Sakib (2020), Sukcesija u međunarodnom pravu. Sukcesija SFRJ, Fakultet za kriminalistiku, kriminologiju i sigurnosne studije Univerziteta u Sarajevu, Sarajevo

Sornarajah, Muthucumaraswamy (2004), The International Law on Foreign Investment, 2. izd., Cambridge University Press

Sornarajah, Muthucumaraswamy (2021), The International Law on Foreign Investment, 5. izd., Cambridge University Press

Šarin, Duška (2014), ˝Konvencija za zaštitu ljudskih prava i temeljnih sloboda kroz odnos Europskog suda za ljudska prava i Ustavnog suda Republike Hrvatske na primjeru zaštite ljudskog prava na pristup Sudu˝, Pravni vjesnik, 30(3-4), 77-100.

Terrien, Armand (2023), ˝Jurisdiction Ratione Temporis; dostupno na: https://jusmundi.com/en/document/publication/en-jurisdiction-ratione-temporis

Vandevelde, Kenneth J. (2010), Bilateral Investment Treaties: History, Policy, and Interpretation, Oxford University Press

Vehabović, Faris (2006), Odnos Ustava Bosne i Hercegovine i Evropske konvencije za zaštitu ljudskih prava i osnovnih sloboda, ACIPS, Sarajevo

Velić, Larisa i Ismet Velić (2021), ˝Odlaganje radioaktivnog otpada˝, Anali Pravnog fakulteta Univerziteta u Zenici, 14(29), 13-34.

Voss, Jan Ole (2011), The Impact of Investment Treaties on Contracts between Host States and Foreign Investors, Studies on the Law on Treaties, vol. 4, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers

Waibel, Michael (2014), Investment Arbitration: Jurisdiction and Admissibility, Legal Studies Research. Paper Series, Paper No. 9/2014, University of Cambridge

Weber, Jörg, Peter Muchlinski, Howard Mann (2005), Investor-State disputes arising from investment treaties: a review, United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, UNCTAD Series on International Investment Policies for Development, UN




DOI: https://doi.org/10.51558/2490-3647.2024.9.1.645

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


ISSN: 2490-3604 (print) ● ISSN: 2490-3647 (online)

Društvene i humanističke studije - DHS is under the Creative Commons licence.