Lack of Trust between Ethnic Groups in Post-Ethnic Conflict Societies: Cases of Zimbabwe and Bosnia-Herzegovina

Berina Beširović, Kudzai Cathrine Bingisai

Abstract


This paper shows how the processes of trust-building and power-sharing are evolving in the cases of Zimbabwe and Bosnia-Herzegovina after the conflict. The paper’s focus lies on lack of trust between different ethnic groups in the post-war period in terms of building political institutions and common political identity. Zimbabwe ethnic tensions originating from the Gukurahundi (1983-1987) between the Shona and the Ndebele people spilt over to the post-ethnic conflict society. Despite having the peace agreement known as the Unity Accord of 1987 to reduce tension in Zimbabwe, power-sharing remains the most untapped area for discussion. Similarly, the war in Bosnia-Herzegovina (1992-1995) and the ethnic distribution of power given by the Dayton Peace Agreement are still one of the most significant elements of uncertainty and insecurity with dysfunctional ethnically based power-sharing as a result. With this review paper, we tend to answer several questions: What is the primary source of distrust and insecurity in post-conflict societies in Zimbabwe and Bosnia concerning the origins of those issues? What are the efforts of state institutions to promote unity and peace, and how do these peace accords affect institution-building processes?

Keywords


peace agreement; Zimbabwe; Bosnia and Herzegovina; ethnic conflict; social cohesion; power-sharing

Full Text:

PDF

References


Alexander, Jocelyn (2021),˝The noisy silence of Gukurahundi: Truth, recognition and belonging˝, Journal of Southern African Studies, 47(5), 763-785.

Bašić, Nedžad (1989), Samoopredjeljenje naroda - jugoslovenski federalizam, KIZ Centar, Beograd

Begić, Kasim I. (1997), Bosna i Hercegovina od Vanceove misije do Daytonskog sporazuma, Bosanska knjiga, Sarajevo

Cameron, Hazel (2018), ˝The Matabeleland massacres: Britain’s willful blindness, The International History Review, 40,1-19.

Carmichale, Cathie (2015), A Concise History of Bosnia, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Chitando, Ezra, Nisbert T. Taringa (2021), ˝The churches, gukurahundi, and forgiveness in Zimbabwe˝, International bulletin of mission research, 45(2), 187-196.

Demirović, Mujo (1999), Bosna i Bošnjaci u srpskoj politici, Ekonomski fakultet, Bihać

Donia, J. Robert (2016), Radovan Karadžić – uzroci, postanak i uspon genocida u Bosni i Hercegovini, University Press, Sarajevo

Dube, Vusimuzi (2014), ˝Uproar over non-Ndebele speaking teachers˝, Inter- net: http://www. bulawayo24. com. Access 29.

Eppel, Shari (2008), ˝Matabeleland: Its Struggle for National Legitimacy, and the Relevance of this in the 2008 Election˝, Perspectives 2(8), 1-7.

Eppel, Shari (2004), ˝’Gukurahundi’, The need for truth and reconciliation˝, in: Brian Raftopoulos and Tyrone Savage (eds.), Zimbabwe Injustice and Political Reconciliation, Institute for Justice and Reconciliation, 43-62.

Filandra, Šaćir (2012), Bošnjaci nakon socijalizma: o bošnjačkom identitetu u postjugoslavenskom dobu, BZK Preporod, Sarajevo

Gova, Munyaradzi, Cleopatra Ndlovu (2013), ˝Gukurahundi healing integrates Nkayi˝, The Zimbabwean, 20 March 2013. Accessed on 20 May 2024 at https://www.thezimbabwean.co/2013/03/gukurahundi-healing-integrates-nkayi/

Government of Zimbabwe (2024), Keynote Address By His Excellency, The President Of The Republic Of Zimbabwe Cde. Dr. E. D. Mnangagwa On The Occasion Of The Launch Of The Gukurahundi Community Outreach Programme State House, Bulawayo 14 July 2024. Available at, https://www. info-min.org.zw/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/Key-Note-Address-Gukurahundi-FINAL-10-JULY-2024-AG-EDIT-1-1.pdf

Grbo, Ismet (1997), Ogledalo nasilja, SDA - Centrala Sarajevo, Sarajevo

Harris, Lulu Brenda (2022), ˝Stakeholders worry over low voter registration in Matabeleland˝, CITE, available at https://cite.org.zw/stakeholders-worry- over-low-voter-registration-inMatabeleland

Hoare, Marko Atila (2007), The History of Bosnia: From the Middle Ages to the Present Day, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge

Hurd, Douglas (1999), The search for peace, Brown Little, London.

Ibrahimagić, Omer (2001), Srpsko osporavanje Bosne i Bošnjaka, Magistrat, Sarajevo

Ibrahimagić, Omer (2008), Politički sistem Bosne i Hercegovine, izdavač autor, Sarajevo

Ibrahimagić, Omer (2016), O Bosni i nama je riječ: razgovori i intervjui 1996- -2016, Monos, Gračanica

Imamović, Enver (2010), Pregled historije Bosne, Kongres Bošnjaka svijeta, Sarajevo

Imamović, Mustafa (2014), Historija države i prava Bosne i Hercegovine, Magistrat, Sarajevo

Korkut, Hasan, Muhidin Mulalić (2012), ˝Implications of Dayton Peace Agreement on Current Political Issues in Bosnia-Herzegovina˝, Süleyman Demirel Üniversitesi Fen-Edebiyat Fakültesi Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi, 2, 107-117.

Kunrath, Birgith (2010), ˝Od zaštitne mjere do prepreke za daljnje djelovanje: entitetsko glasanje u BiH˝, in: Dino Abazović, Stefan Hammer (eds.), Bosna i Hercegovina petnaest godina nakon Daytona”, Fakultet političkih nauka Univerziteta u Sarajevu, Sarajevo, 19-47.

Kurtćehajić, Suad (2017), Prilozi za politički sistem Bosne i Hercegovine, Futur art, Sarajevo

Lucić, Predrag (2005), Stenogrami o podjeli Bosne, Feral Tribune, Split

Maphosa, Khumbulani (2011), ˝Ndebele-Shona relations: recipe for disaster˝, Newsday, 23 February: 6.

Mashingaidze, Terence (2005), ˝The 1987 Zimbabwe National Unity Accord and its aftermath: A case of peace without reconciliation?˝, in: Cheryl Hendricks and Lwazi Lushaba (eds.), From national liberation to democratic renaissance in Southern Africa, CODESRIA, 82-92.

Moyo, Lungisani, Limukani Mathe (2014), ˝Network analysis of immigrants’ social interaction in the diaspora. A case study of Zimbabweans at University of Fort Hare Alice Campus South Africa˝, Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences, 5(23), 1541-1552.

Moyo-Nyoni, Ntombizakhe (2022), ˝Digital Storytelling as a Tool for Peacebuilding in Post-Conflict Matabeleland˝, in: Kanyile Mlothsva and Mphathisi Ndlovu, The Idea of Matabeleland in Digital Spaces: Genealogies, Discourses, and Epistemic Struggles, Lexinton Books, 47-62.

Muchemwa, Cyprian (2016), Building friendships between Shona and Ndebele ethnic groups in Zimbabwe, PhD Thesis, Durban University of Technology

Murambadoro, Ruth (2015), ˝‘We cannot reconcile until the past has been acknowledged’: Perspectives on Gukurahundi from Matabeleland, Zim- babwe˝, African Journal on Conflict Resolution, 15(1), 33-57.

Murambadoro, Ruth, Cori Wielenga (2015), ˝Reconciliation in Zimbabwe: the conflict between a state-centred and people-centered approach˝, The Strategic Review for Southern Africa, 37(1), 31-52

Muzondidya, James, Sabelo Ndlovu-Gatsheni (2007), ˝‘Echoing Silences’: Ethnicity in post-colonial Zimbabwe, 1980-2007˝, African Journal on Conflict Resolution, 7(2), 275-297.

Ndakaripa, Musiwao (2014), ˝Ethnicity, narrative, and the 1980s violence in the Matabeleland and Midlands provinces of Zimbabwe˝, in: Oral History Forum d’histoire orale, Vol. 34, Special Issue on Human Rights and Oral History, 1-47.

Ndlovu, Mphathisi (2023), ˝Child Survivors, Witnessing and Memories of Gukurahundi: An Analysis of The Children of the Genocide (2021) Documentary Film˝, in: Remembering Mass Atrocities: Perspectives on Memory Struggles and Cultural Representations in Africa. Springer International Publishing, 113-133.

Ndlovu-Gatsheni, Sabelo (2008), ˝For the nation to live, the tribe must die: The politics of Ndebele identity and belonging in Zimbabwe˝, In: Bahru Zewde (ed.), Society, state and identity in African history, Forum for Social Studies, 167-200.

Ndlovu-Gatsheni, Sabelo (2009), ˝Mapping cultural and colonial encounters, 1880s-1930s˝, in: Brian Raftopoulos, Alois S. Mlambo, (eds.), Becoming Zimbabwe: a History from the Pre-colonial Period to 2008, Jacana Media, Johannesburg, 39-74.

Ngwenya, Dumisani, Geoff Harris (2015), ˝The consequences of not healing: Evidence from the Gukurahundi violence in Zimbabwe˝, African Journal on Conflict Resolution, 15(2), 35-55.

Oven Dejvid, (1996), Balkanska odiseja, 4. Izdanje, Svjedoci povijesti, Beograd

Pattenden, Hugh (2023), ˝The Representation of the British Government in Zimbabwean Nationalist Propaganda, 1965–80˝, Journal of Contemporary History, 58(1), 152-176.

Pejanović, Mirko (1997), Sadašnjost i politička budućnost Bosne i Hercegovine, Vijeće Kongresa bošnjačkih intelektualaca, Sarajevo

Pejanović, Mirko (1999), Bosansko pitanje i Srbi u Bosni i Hercegovini, Bosanska knjiga, Sarajevo

Pejanović, Mirko (2005), Politički razvitak Bosne i Hercegovine u postdejtonskom periodu, TDK Šahinpašić, Sarajevo

Pellet, Alain (1992), ˝The Opinions of the Badinter Arbitration Committee: A Second Breath for the Self-determination of Peoples˝, European Journal of International Law, 92(1), 178–185.

Ray, Charles, Michael Walsh (2024), ˝Changing the Status Quo in US-Zimbabwe Relations˝, Orbis, 68(2), 190-210.

Reim, Lena (2023), ˝‘Gukurahundi Continues’: Violence, Memory, and Mthwakazi Activism in Zimbabwe˝, African Affairs. 122(486), 95-117.

Saltaga, Fuad (1997), Bosna i Bošnjaci u srpskoj nacionalnoj ideologiji, Salfu, Sarajevo

Trnka, Kasim (2000), Konstitutivnost naroda: Povodom odluke Ustavnog suda Bosne i Hercegovine o konstitutivnosti Bošnjaka, Hrvata i Srba na nivou entiteta, Vijeće kongresa bošnjačkih intelektualaca, Gračanica

Tshuma, Darlington (2018), ˝Reconciliation, integration and healing efforts in Zimbabwe˝ Conflict Trends, 2018/2, 19-26.

Tshuma, Lungile Augustine, Mphathisi Ndlovu (2022), ˝Immortalizing “buried memories”: Photographs of the Gukurahundi online˝, Journal of Genocide Research, 24(3), 380-401.

Tshuma, Mandla (2021), ˝Political parties blame ZEC for poor voter registration in Matabelelan˝, 16 June 2021. CITE. Accessed on 20 May 2024 at: https://cite.org.zw/political-parties-blame-zec-for-poor-voter-registration-in-matabeleland/

Ugochukwu, Osondu (2023), ˝State apologies, postcolonial resistance and ontological insecurity: the Matabeleland massacre˝, Third World Quarterly 44(5), 1039-1057.

Vambe, Maurice Taonezvi (2012), ˝Zimbabwe genocide: voices and perception on “development” and “democracy” from the youth and old people of Matabeleland and the Midlands provinces 32 years on˝, Commonwealth Youth and Development, 10(1)

Williams, Lewis, Ronald Labonte, Mike O’Brien. (2003), ˝Empowering social action through narratives of identity and culture˝, Health Promotion Interna- tional, 18(1), 33-40.

Zgodić, Esad (2005), Bosanski rukopis Omera Ibrahimagića, Promocult, Sarajevo

Zimbabwe Constitution (2013), Government Printers. Harare, Zimbabwe

Zimbabwe National Statistics Agency. (ZIMSTAT) (2022), Zimbabwe 2022 Population and Housing Census. Preliminary Report, Zimbabwe National Statistics Agency, Harare, Zimbabwe




DOI: https://doi.org/10.51558/2490-3647.2024.9.2.333

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


ISSN: 2490-3604 (print) ● ISSN: 2490-3647 (online)

Društvene i humanističke studije - DHS is under the Creative Commons licence.